Three novelty brands have received demand letters this year over product names they have used since before the registrations existed. In each case the mark was filed recently, in a class that covers the product, by a party with no apparent connection to the industry.

The economics favour the sender. Filing a trademark costs a few hundred dollars. A demand letter costs a stamp. A response from a brand's lawyer costs $2,000 to $6,000, and a marketplace complaint that triggers a listing suspension costs far more in lost sales than the settlement being asked for.

What actually defends a name

Use, documented. A brand that can show ten years of invoices, packaging proofs and advertising carrying the name has a defensible position even against a later registration. The problem is that most brands have the usage and not the file, and reconstructing it under a deadline is expensive.

“We had nine years of invoices in a folder nobody had opened since 2019.”Brand manager who settled a demand

Two of the three brands settled for $4,000 to $12,000 rather than fight, because the marketplace suspension risk was larger than the demand. The third fought, spent $31,000, and kept the name after the registration was cancelled — a result that reads as a win and cost more than the settlement would have.

The preventive work is cheap: keep a digital file per product name with first-use date, packaging artwork, invoices and the listing URLs; register the names that matter in the classes that matter; and check the register before a launch rather than after.

Key takeaways

  • Recent filings on long-used product names are producing demand letters across the novelty sector.
  • A demand costs the sender a stamp and the brand $2,000–$6,000 to answer.
  • Documented first use is the defence; most brands have the usage but not the file.
PR

Priya Raghunathan · Legal & policy correspondent

Reads statutes for a living. Covers age verification, reporting duties and contract disputes across US states.